Short answer: give feedback soon after the event, in private if it is corrective, and make it about a specific behaviour rather than the person. Describe the situation, the behaviour you saw and its impact, then stop and ask for their view. Agree what happens next. Do this often enough that feedback becomes normal rather than an event people dread.
A simple structure: Situation, Behavior, Impact
The Situation-Behavior-Impact model, developed by the Center for Creative Leadership, keeps feedback factual and short.
- Situation: when and where. "In Tuesday's client call..."
- Behavior: what the person said or did, described so that a camera could have recorded it. "...you answered the pricing question before the client had finished explaining their concern..."
- Impact: the effect it had. "...and they repeated the concern twice more, so the call ran over and we didn't get to next steps."
Then ask: "How did it look from your side?" That question turns a verdict into a conversation, and you will often learn something that changes your view.
Corrective feedback, step by step
- Check your intent. The goal is a better result next time, not proving a point.
- Do it soon and in private. Within a day or two, while the details are fresh.
- Use SBI. One behaviour per conversation. A list of five things is a performance review, not feedback.
- Ask and listen. Let them explain before you suggest anything.
- Agree the next step. "What would you do differently next time?" works better than prescribing.
- Follow up. Notice when they do it differently and say so.
Positive feedback needs the same precision
"Great job" is pleasant and forgettable. Specific positive feedback tells people what to repeat: "When you summarised the three options in one slide before the debate started, the leadership team made the call in ten minutes. Do that again for the budget review." Give it as readily as corrective feedback.
Common mistakes
- The feedback sandwich. Wrapping criticism between two compliments trains people to distrust your praise and often hides the actual message.
- Judging character. "You're careless" invites defence. "The figures in section two didn't match the source file" invites a fix.
- Saving it up. Feedback delivered months later, at review time, feels like an ambush.
- Feedback by email or chat for anything sensitive. Tone gets lost; have the conversation.
- Not asking for feedback yourself. Managers who ask "What should I do more or less of?" get a team that receives feedback better.
When they push back
Stay curious rather than defensive. Restate what you heard, check the facts together, and separate disagreement about what happened from disagreement about what to do next. If emotions run high, it is fine to pause and continue the next day. For heavier conversations, see how to have difficult conversations.
Make it routine
The easiest place for regular feedback is the one-on-one. A standing question such as "What's one thing from this week you'd do differently, and one thing I could do differently?" makes feedback two-way and expected. Over time this is what builds psychological safety: people learn that hearing about a problem early leads to help, not blame.
Common questions
What is the SBI feedback model?
Situation-Behavior-Impact, a model from the Center for Creative Leadership: describe when and where it happened, the specific behaviour you observed, and the effect it had.
How often should managers give feedback?
Often enough that it feels normal. Weekly or fortnightly one-on-ones are a natural place for it, alongside quick comments soon after specific events.
Should feedback be given in private?
Corrective feedback should be private. Specific positive feedback can be given publicly if the person is comfortable with that.
Is the feedback sandwich effective?
Usually not. Surrounding criticism with compliments can hide the message and makes people distrust future praise.
What should I do if an employee disagrees with my feedback?
Listen, restate what you heard, check the facts together, and separate disagreement about what happened from agreement on what to do next.
Take the next step
Book a free 30-minute discovery session. A conversation about fit, with no obligation.